Winners of the
U Pick’em Think Tank Photo Contest were selected at random using the Random.Org True Random Number
Generator. Watch the video for comments by Al Diaz on the editing process of all four of his images
First place winner is Will Fagan!
Second place is
Patrick Fallon!
Third place is
Karen Vaisman!
Entrants were
asked to post comments on which one of four photographs they would choose for
publication. There were a total of 132 entries.
Image one
received 26 votes
Image two
received 61 votes
Image three
received 19 votes
Image four
received 26 votes
1. Brett Flashnick I would go for #2. Tight is right in this instance. Wider
images don't offer any more context than #2.
2. Chuck Burton Number
two...great expression, nice tight action.
5.
David Hearne No.2. It is
the most energetic and because it is near the rim most suggestive of a powerful
dunk. The physicality of Lebron is emphasized. However, I would want a an image
before this one. As a sports editor I would not use any of these.
6. Thomas Staub
I would select #1. It nicely shows that in this situation
the San Antonio Spurs are powerless / helpless to prevent the Monster slam
of LeBron James. Number 21 is far away. In addition, #1 shows the full
power of the dunk.
7. John Simpson #4 since it
shows context (in the air, near the net, frustration, minimal people noise),
that some of the other shots don't show. All great shots, but some are
definitely better than others.
9.
David Tulis I'm going
with the "tight is right" version number 2, top right. Nice flick by
the way!
10.John Lechner Number 3, it conveys the motion/action plus gives a real
feeling of flying. I love this shot. So much to look at from LeBron's face to
the ball, his body position to how far he is off the ground.
12.zZLiana Lehua I like #3, because it conveys more info about what happened
with Tony Parker looking defeated and easing up. It shows LeBron still
elevated.
13.Wellington Guzman I'd pick #1 based on the opponent and
how useless it is to try to catch up to him, how fast he's moved up the court,
and the power of the dunk.
15.Heidi Christensen I would go with #4. You see that he is jumping but you
can also see his reaction; it shows the moment fully that he comes in contact
with the ball.
16.Jake Valerio I would choose #3 because I like to see everything in a shot
and it really how's how far up he actually is.
17.Brian Davidson I pick number two because its peak action and the crop is the
tightest. It also has the cleanest background.
18.Will Fagan #1: Great face, good action, beaten opponent in the
background. The opponent in the back makes the image better than the rest, and
helps tell the story of the Heat winning the game. #3 is too far from peak
action to be the story, with too much dead space at the top. The composition of
#1 leads you through the image the best.
19.David Seelig I would pick number 2 it has more impact then the others I like
seeing his face so up front.
22.Sword Bomber Photo 3 coz he is not connected with the ball... he looks
like doing 'Air Bending' (The Last Airbender movie)... and he is on air.
23.Fuad Azzad The best
option is the 3rd one. Is the only image in which the ball is not in contact
with the body – an important feature in basketball. On the other hand, it tells
a complete story by including the referee, the coach and the player of the
opposite team. This places us in a real game where the action is taking place.
The movement presented by this photograph is of a hand moving towards the ball,
as oppose to the others where the ball is hitting the body. The intentionality
of the player is best perceived the third shot.
24.Carl D. Schumacher I'd go with #1. You get the
sense of power that the other shots show, but with the opponent in the
background, there's more of an overall story. The other player is trying
to catch up, but you can see the full perspective of the court, making him and
the other end very small.
25.Craig Sheppard My eye is immediately drawn to #2 but I would publish #1. For
me #1 puts the player in context. You can see the court, the other
players, the crowd and the hoop.
27.Tzehau Tong Hey Al, I would publish the #4 because it has better
angle shot. #4 shows the lebron's whole body dynamic movement
right after the moster jam in the air. Besides, the angle of shot
catches lebron' s no. 6 on the shirt and the miami heats logo clearly and
nice.
28.Alex Eberhart I would pick picture 2 because it gets you up close shows how
high he got off the ground by how close he is to the rim.
29.Niall Scully No.4 feels right to me, the composition, being able to see the
full body with no distractions around. Thanks! :)
30.Jay Loden I guess I'll be the odd man out, I'd go with #1 myself. None of
these are bad shots of course, but #1 looks almost like ballet! The different
angle makes his feet look crossed like he's doing a graceful pirouette,
opposing team player in the background for context, ball positioning works
better for me, and as a bonus you've got a cool diagonal line with his body
drawing the eye right through the frame.
31.Simone Renoldi n° 2... it's more direct, no distraction about the backgrounds.
It goes directly to the target!
32.amanda logiodice In number 3 you just don't know what will come next, it's
intriguing :) I would totally pick number 3, love the reflection off the court,
love that his feet are both in the air but look relaxed
33.Gary Cosby Jr. It has to number 2 if I am a photo editor. Image
number 2 is the tightest shot and gives you the ball, the face and the arms
with a clean background. My second choice is number 1. If I have
space to play with I go with number 1 because I like seeing the separation
LeBron gets with Tim Duncan trailing way behind. That kind of makes a
statement all its own.
34.
Erika
Muller love the facial expression of LeBron in photo 2. Also, it
has the cleanest background and depicts the shot block perfectly.
35. Gregory
Antonio Castillo Photo
2! The tightest zoom fills the frame perfectly and puts the viewer right where
the action is.
36. Richard
Shumaker I think the
first image (#1) tells the best story - you have more fans showing, the
"Fan Zone" on the big screen and the opposition way back down court
staring somewhat in amazement with a "what now" look on his face.
The complete package.
37.
Mike
Hylandsson Hi
Al!! I would publish #2 because you get everything! 1) Scale - yup,
that's his head, nearly hitting the net! So you know he's up high (you
don't need to see his feet to know that) 2) Since it's framed tight (relative
to the others) you can see his facial expression - that puts more weight &
impact to the image and finally 3) The ball is near him, his arms are flexed
(and ripped, haha) - all that adds to the dynamism. Good work, Al!
Cheers, Mike
38.
S
Garcia I would fly with number 4. The one frame tells a story.
The details are enough for the viewer to decipher what took place with
interest. Besides being a cool shot, it also has some great details.
39. David
Emm Number 2 all the
way. It shows the immediate aftermath of the dunk, the background is clean,
there is enough else in the image to show the surroundings, but not to be
distracting, and the crop is tight enough to draw attention right to the player
and yet not feel cramped for space. In number 1 the player in the background is
a little distracting and the shot isnt wide enough to show the height off the
ground which doesn't do the body position justice. Number 3 you have the player
popping in the side of the image and Mr James is too far down after the peak
moment to show the dynamism of the dunk. Number 4 doesn't show the enough of
the floor so you get no real impression of height off the ground.
40.
Paulo
Gomes I agree the 2nd
has quite an impact, but... I would choose the 4th, just because it gives a
better sense of the enviroment, with the packed audience, the player in mid-air
and the referee trying to catch up with the play ;) its a much better
story then the 2nd.
41. Donald
Withers Al - I'd go
with 4. There's a lot going on in the frame like the crowd and th
42. Roman
Andrei I would choose
#2 ,he captured my attention.It show the best expression,and u can see the face
expression,nice job :)
43. Jeremy
Glover #2..Cleaner
background. You see his facial expression better. It tells the story
better..That the ball just came out of the net. Other photos have too
many distractions such as other people or signage that takes your eye away from
the main focus of the shot.
44. Nilesh Soni
1 and 3 would be my pick over here;
If I have to chose one, I would go with #3. it shows the opposite team players
face, who sort of gave it up. Kind of dictates who is the boss on the court and
all eyes on him. My email:
45.
Doug
Searles I would
choose photo number 4 since it shows the whole body of LeBron James after the
monster jam. Not only that but it actually will show exactly how far off the
ground he was to show the height difference. Also as you look into the background
you can see the opposing coach and his frustration. Also by having LeBron in
focus throws out the fans in the stands but it gives you that larger than life
feeling and shows how much each of the game.
46. Kitty Mason
Number 2 is my pick! Shows
everything you need to see to know the story of that shot and captures a close
up of his brawn.
47. Bryon Cole
I like #4, its got all the action and
expression in one frame. The background is just as important and you can see
how he was captured in mid-air. The net has some nice motion and the look on
his face is priceless.
49. Josiah Alter
I woud definitely choose #3 or #4
depending on how much fill you use...
52. Maura van der
Linden I'd go with
#2 - I like the up close view of his face, the implicit effort and
relationship with the net and the ball against his chest. I also like the lack
of too many additional distractions behind him - the red banner is easier for
me to ignore than the other player or the white banner by his feet. The ball
into the net is the goal, not the feet in the air :)
53. Jade
Falcon I prefer #1.
It shows a relationship between the opposing player, himself, and the ball.
54. Rusty
Burroughs I like the
close crop of #2 .... Powerful! less distracting background and facial
expression is great.
55. Aaron
Cushing I'd send #2,
since the editor is probably gonna crop it in anyway. I like ti tighter, and
without the bald dude between his legs from #4 ;-)
56. djdanny ray
Great site . I could spend day
and night talking and reading about photography. Keep it going.
Thanks.
57. Phoenix
Spiritdiva I pick
#4. Love the CU and #4 captures it all. . . from the jump to the
spread hands to the chest bounce/toss that won the shot. . . you captured the
magic of this winning shot...LBJ and your photo.
58. Tom Collins
I would vote for #2. It is a tight
shot which isolates LBJ. You see his face, expression, and the number on his
jersey. The background is clean and undistracting. The location of LBJ's arms
suggest that the goal was made through divine intervention.
59. Joann Biondi
Number 2, because I like looking at
his arms.
60. Phelan
Ebenhack I like photo
#2. Peak action, reaction. And I'd run it big!
61. Bradley
Marshall I would
select #4. It shows full body, head close to the rim, hands in balance,
captures the heat logo and his number 6 clearly, and the space below
reflects the elevation of the action. He looks off balance in shots 1 &
3. #2 seems just to be a close up of #4, and I hate cut off limbs if you
are not going for more of a close-up. #4 also get the NBA Cares into the
shot. additional
62. Ray
Whitehouse I like photo
number three the best because you have the referee, Greg Popovich and Tony
Parker adding context to the frame.
63. Mark
Wallheiser Photography #2
would have been my first image moved.
64. Andrew
Williams I would pick
#2. The other 3 photos have some distracting elements such as the other player
who is not relevant in #1, and the NBA signboards in #3 and #4. Photo #2 places
the greatest focus on the most important elements - the ball, the hoop and the
player. It also allows you to see his face and expression, which gives the
viewer a greater connection with the moment.
65. Adam
Nikoletsos Number
1. Showing Tim Duncan in the background after the dunk makes LeBron look
even better!
67. Philip Chan
1st one has the best pose/angle IMO.
The other 3 are similar but are from a side angle.
68. Rica Espiritu
#2 Aside from the shot being "tight", concise and showing
everything that the person needs to know, coming from a 'print' background,
even if this pic gets printed as a thumbnail, it gets the message across. You
don't have to blow it up or get a full page view to see what you 'need to
know'. As long as the photo gets the message across, that's what I will pick.
69. Billie
Beltran pic #1,
full frame shot, he is in the air with a full house behind him. best part is
like he is "Shot and Nailed In The Air!"
70. Charles
Simmons #1 would be my
choice for publication. It shows the moment of confirmation of the end to me.
Showing a Lebron James far ahead of the opposing team with Tim Duncan watching
helplessly from the background but also showing Lebron to be leading the pack
with a Miami teammate in the background witnessing the slam unfold. It portrays
the dominance the we all witnessed Lebron showing down the stretch of the 2013
NBA Finals by showing him as, pun intended, playing leaps and bounds above not
only his opponents but also his own teammates. The composition also draws the
reader in close to the action but still shows an interesting backdrop with the
dejected Spurs fans in a moment of foreshadowing of San Antonio's eventual
collapse. By showing the reaction, or lack thereof, of the crowd, the photo
exudes the feeling of "Dominance" to me and speaks emotionally and
photographically in the perfect way to describe the play that Lebron and the Heat
showed throughout the year and on their way to the repeat. I think all four
photos are fitting but #1 does the best job of combining all of the elements
needed to perfectly describe the Miami Heat's 2013 Season and Championship
Playoff run.
72. Jim Merchant
I would select #2 as it fully shows
his facial expression and crops out the manager between his legs. Its the old
get in tight and fill the frame with the subject!
73. Christofer
Lindkvist I would go with
#1 for a few reasons. It's the only one you can see anyone else from the game
and you might figure out what he's thinking and it looks like Lebron is
enormous and is standing on his toes. Fantastic picture!
74. Scott
Sideleau When in doubt,
go with the tight crop. I'd go with #2 because it shows the action (just
after the slam dunk) without any other distracting elements or opportunities
for misrepresentation (e.g. #1 almost looks like he's dancing on the court in a
bad PhotoChop).
75. Spencer
Pablo #3. His full
body's in the shot, and you've got crowds and ref in the shot. Also, because it also looks like he's
playing volleyball or can pew-pew balls from his chest. Multisport. Diversify.
76. Luis Sytsma
#4 shows him the moment after
throwing down, his pose still contains a powerful look and the court is cropped
out so it seems hes still high up there. also the pose isnt awkward as the
other photos. lebron is the leader of the team, lebron #4 with good composition
and poise.
77. Jonathan
Abrenica I like #1,
Duncan in the background seems fitting. Would of picked #4 but I don't
really like how Popovich is peaking between his legs.
78. Kevin Huang
Why not make it solely about LeBron
with photo 2? He seems to think that's what it's all about, might as well play
to it.
79. Matt Wicks
I would opt for Image #1 for
storytelling purposes, as it shows Tim Duncan far behind on the court,
representing the Spurs trailing the Heat. Great options here.
80. Marcel Bauer I am really digging pic #4, the expression, frozen
movement are perfect. I can totally hear the roar of the crowd.
Great capture.
81. Anthony
Marshall I would choose
the first picture. I like the body posture of LeBron and how he is
slightly at an angle with his hands in the air like "Thats how we
roll". I also like how you can see Duncan in the back behind LeBron
probably super blown. So in conclusion I like the fact that his whole
body is in the picture, you see the court and the crowd.
82. Irma
Gutierrez I would pick
the second photograph being the 4th, cropped even more so that his facial
expression is the most visible, creating emphasis on derail and the emotion of
the photograph. Detail***
83. Lisa Smith# 3 for sure. love how his back arches.
it is a winner for me
84. Peggy
P I would choose #4.
It looks like a cover shot. LeBron looks like he's floating, he's
well-centered, and the ref and fans are visible. That shot makes me feel
like I'm there.
85. Kent
Nishimura Hrm. tough
choice...i think i'd select 3, definitely if it was cropped a heckuva lot
tighter. there are some definite possibilities with frame 3. it's just
difficult to say with the photographs being small.
86. Elan Kawesch
I'd go with number 2. The crop at
the knees is not a huge deal, and by doing that, you get a better background
than the rest, and a better view of Lebron's face. For the cover of a sports
section, it has an instant "pop" that will draw readers into buying
the paper.
87. Ibrahim Cetindemir
I would publish #2. You see, photo #
1 tells the story but the net seems distracting. I can say the same thing for
#3. The player on the left, the ref and the guy in the suit all draw me away
and clutter the frame. As for #4 its a great capture, but we don't want the
lettering on the bottom, nor the ref, let alone the guy in the suit.
Thats why I would had also cropped photo #4 and publish #2.
88. Patrick
Fallon Looks like #4 is
the pick here, though I'm curious what more reaction shots might look like.
90. Christopher
Trim I'd go with #1. I
like the reverse angle as it shows Tim Duncan in the background and helps to
establish that this was shot during the NBA finals.
91. Carlos
Rodrigues I will number
3, just because the face of disappointment of the Spurs player, give the
both sides of the story.
93. Matt Gade
2nd, Tighter and better facial
expression. Background is more compressed and not as busy, no coaches behind
his legs as in 3 and 4. Might even crop from the bottom to just over his
waistline or just under his right arm.
94.
John
Williamson Al, these are all superb images... the type that
sports photojournalists dream of catching at just that right time. Extremely
tough decision, but with only one to pick from, I would have to go with
number 2, as it perfectly capture the emotion that LeBron James had
to be feeling at that precise moment!
95. Lou Novick Hi Al, I pick #2 as the best, I can't leave a comment
on your blog don't know why.
96.Jose Dominguez Photo #3 is the winner to me. The story is there. Lebron is
there full body, Parker comes into the pic. and the referee and the crowd is in
the background.
97.John McG Shot #2 is my
choice for the following reasons:
-
The viewer is drawn to Lebron's face
and the emotion of the moment
-
The elements of the game (crowd,
ball, rim) are all present
-
The crop removes the awkward
positioning of Lebron's legs/feet
-
The viewer (or at least me) can feel
the power of the dunk That's all I've got. :)
98.Alan Youngblood #2 is my favorite. Very nice moment with good impact. Tighter
then
the others so it has greater impact. The great expression is not lost. Nice Job Al.
the others so it has greater impact. The great expression is not lost. Nice Job Al.
100.
Angelique Carter #3 it looks like a pic that would b in the magazine. Its
something about the ball off to it self and then him at a diagonal. that shows
the power over the ball.
101.
Tom Burton I'd go with
#2. The frame is closest to the moment of the dunk and for the later frames,
it's not as apparent that he made the basket. The expression reads better from
that angle compared to #3 and the tighter crop makes it read quicker. And if
the hole on the sports front was a horizontal, you could hack a crop from that
one, though not without a bit of pain.
102.
David Poller Frame #1.
The ball and James' face are lined up almost on the lens axis, so you get full
great expression and some nice layers. The background is full of great content
and more layering, like Duncan just standing there helpless, the shot clock,
etc. The visual size of James over the opposition - due to perspective - makes
for a great metaphor of his dominant play. If the photo is going to lead the
page, you've got room to play it monster big vertical, getting the full
balletic posture from King James there. Plus the background neon totally annoys
me in frames 2, 3 & 4. :-)
103.
Michael Lopez Hi Al, I
would pick number 2. It's a good close up of Lebron after he dunked the ball
and you don't need the rest of the body to tell the story. His facial
expression is great and I am right there with him... that is my choice.
104.
Rick McCawley #2 is it!
Impact emotion composition make this a sure thing lead photo run BIG. I'm sure
other published photos would frame the complete story in support of this
decisive moment.
105.
Nicholas R. Von Staden It's door #2...tight crop and run it BIG...let the reader see
his emotion.
107.
Scotty Robson Hi Al, I
would choose number 3 for lots of good reasons. The ball is a little lower and
further away from his chest, and his arms are a little lower and further
back too, which gives the impression of him pushing his chest out - which is a
classic "in your face" capture. Particularly when you see the
resigned face of his opponent to the left hand edge of the photo. And with his
right hand fully open, it feels like a "POW" moment too - you can
almost hear his saying it. The basket still has the classic "swish"
going on, so you know exactly what's happened. The crowd are nicely blown out
without being too blurry or distracting from the action in the foreground
108.
Karen Vaisman #2 shows the expression and the crop of the arms are leading
lines drawing you into the face and puffed out cheeks. The background is more
blurred and less distracting. Although 2 and 4 look like the identical image,
the #2 crop is much more powerful. Excellent job!
109.
Sarah Hoffman #2 I like
the clean background and it brings attention to the moment without the
distracting background. Maybe seeing some reaction in the background would add
context but in this case the expression and moment has the most impact. Awesome
catch!
111.
Lawrence Zicherman I like #2. They are all super shots, but I'll tell you why I
like this one: They all have great expressions on their faces, but I like two
things about this one. First, I like the way he stands out from the crowd --
the blur of the crowd and the shadow on them, while the court lighting on
LeBron really sets him apart. The other reason is that it has the best image of
the net "resetting" after the ball went through, so there is no
question that the ball had just fallen through.
112.
Ryan Henriksen #2. I like the crop from #4 to clean the background and for
impact. #1 is a great angle but I don't think there is enough emotion in the
background to warrant keeping it wide. Great moment
113.
tod grubbs Hi, I would choose shot #2, it is closeup, a
bit more drama than the other shots and shows more emotion of the player as the
ball bounces off him after the slam dunk... IMO!!!
114.
David Gruskin I would
select number 4 because it best captures the sense of the action and show
Lebron getting air. My email is davidjgruskin@gmail.com
115.
Pat Mahoney Mahoney Definitely image number 1. A nice full body shot in
mid-air with the arena environment allowing a lot of depth. And with the
opponent in the back ground at or near the 3-point line Lebron seems to
out-distance the opposition! Color is terific as is the highlights on hie face
and left shoulder/arm!
116.
Jeffrey Reedy The number
2 for the composition, his expression, the angle, is a perfect shoot, your mind
can see that he is in the air without see his feet!
117.
Aaron Srader I like the
fourth pic because it captures all the elements of the shot. To me it has
better composition..
118.
George Guba #2. I think
the medium closeup emphasizes his effort and strength. It captured my attention.
120.
Michał Czekański I would choose 2nd
one, to my opinion it shows the best expression + it's also a tight shoot. It
doens't contain any distracting elements as well as it has the nicest
composition.
121.
Keith Lucas #4 is my favorite...FUll body with Popovich and referee in
background. Facial expression still visible and looking toward the basket can
tell what actually happened! (DUNK)
122.
Liviu H image #1 a lot of
informations being present there: fast attack [clock @ 20s], Tim Duncan
far from defending his basket, game played @ Spurs...
123.
Brandon Larkin I would publish #4. It gives him a cocky kind of look and
I think that matches his public image well.
124.
Michael Clevenger I'd pick #4. I think #4 shows
his proximity to the rim better, with his feet in the frame and the net still
in disarray from the stuff.
125.
Brandon Larkin I would publish #4. It gives him a cocky kind of look and
I think that matches his public image well.
126.
Zsolt Repasy I'd select
#2 as the face is really expressive, there are no disturbing elements in the
image (narrow cropping).
127.
Jin Huynh 2 is the best depiction of an epic dunk out of the four.
The close angle looking up at LeBron shows how he's larger than life (the
blurred crowd behind him). His hands up like that, to me, is body language for
"Boom! There it is!"
128.
Deborah Gray Mitchell I prefer #3...I like that it has both a Spurs player and a
referee, it shows his feet are definitely off the ground and I like that
the ball is in the air. Yes, #2 is good too but it could have been shot
at any game.
129.
Richard Gibson #2 - looks like the basketball is glued to LeBron's chest
- I love sharp sport's images!
130.
George Quiroga #2 - This image crops out some of the distracting elements from
the full frame and focuses the viewer on the emotion and intensity in LeBron's
face. Yet there are still enough background elements to show a packed house. I
also like the composition with the arm diagonally leading up to the
corner to give it more of a dynamic. The energy seems to be concentrated in the
triangle between the hoop, the ball, and LeBron's face keeping my gaze in that
area.
131.
Hal Yeager #2 for
sure. It's tighter, good expression and the lighting is good. Has the three
elements that make a great picture. 1) Quality of light, 2) graphically
pleasing, plus doesn't leave any room for a page editor to destroy it. 3)
Invokes and emotion. It says wam! bam! thank you mam! Which def leads you to
believe they won the game.
132.
Mark Elias No. 2: Big
impactful image which shows the heat of the moment (yes, pun intended) in Game
4. Background is too distracting in other images. This gets the point across to
the viewer in less than a second, while the others have you thinking "well
how did LeBron get into that position? How could he let that happen? etc etc.
Special Thanks to Our Sponsors:
No comments:
Post a Comment